
Posters for events that feel wrong, songs that sound robotic or videos of people that don’t quite feel human — generative artificial intelligence (AI) is producing it all at breakneck speeds, flooding markets around the world at an unprecedented rate. In the art world, many musicians, photographers, architects, graphic designers and a plethora of artists from other mediums view AI as a common fear in the back of their minds. Programs like Suno, ChatGPT and Adobe Firefly are being used by droves on social media to generate a wide variety of content with little to no effort, overshadowing the work of those who spent years honing their craft. Some like Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI, are even going as far as to hail AI art as “a big net win for society,” stating that although AI creates job loss, it ultimately lowers the barriers to entry for people who want to make art. However, that begs the question that many artists are asking: What about us? Despite this wave of unease, AI can never authentically replace the work of human artists, no matter how advanced the systems may be.
In order to discern whether AI replacing artists is truly a threat, we first must ask the question of what art truly is. Merriam-Webster defines art as “the conscious use of skill and creative imagination especially in the production of aesthetic objects.” According to this definition, AI can’t create art because AI isn’t conscious — it’s an algorithm. Regardless of what it’s actually producing, data regurgitated by a series of zeroes and ones can never truly be considered art in the long run, and thus it cannot truly replace the work of human artists.
Nevertheless, AI is still profoundly impacting the art industry on a business level. According to an article by the Stanford Graduate School of Business, because AI is able to create content at such blistering speeds, the market is beginning to consist largely of AI-created works. This has caused a displacement of the work of real artists, and while this does technically benefit consumers, it comes at the cost of artists competing with highly optimized computer algorithms, often being forced to make sacrifices that they wouldn’t have to otherwise. In other words, artists are experiencing something reminiscent of a modern day version of John Henry scenario, struggling to outcompete the oppressive steam engine that is generative AI.
On that same note, these attempts by artists to compete with AI are also indirectly feeding it. According to LMU Magazine, “AI generators rely on databases of already existing art, the internet being a massive trove of readily available resources. Images are ‘scraped’ from the internet and used as data. Generators are ‘trained,’ or taught, to recognize art. Based on human prompts and drawing from thousands or millions of images, they can produce a new image that meets particular specifications.” This “scraping” of works from the internet is pertinent because it means that the work of real artists is being used to condition AI, without artists’ consent and without compensation. This can be illegal depending on the data that was being collected and where it was collected from. One example of this is when the estate of Elvis Presley sued generative AI company Anthropic, the tech behemoth behind Claude, for $41 million as a result of their nonconsensual use of his work to train their AI models.
Some people, like the aforementioned CEO of OpenAI, Sam Altman, look at things in a different light when it comes to generative AI. On X in 2022, Sam Altman posted, “Artists will be much more productive and have new capabilities, but the barrier to entry will be much lower. And as the tools get better, ‘regular people’ will be able to do almost anything they want themselves. Eventually this will happen almost everywhere.” In a sense, Altman is actually correct in his assertion that AI art creates a significantly lower skill floor for those who want to create quickly and easily. However, this isn’t as perfect as it may seem. First and foremost, in the United States you cannot legally copyright completely AI-generated images, meaning that whatever you generate in ChatGPT or other services is not yours per se, but rather under the ownership of the model in which you generated it. Moreover, how valuable is this low barrier to entry in the first place? The UN reports that AI could lead to as much as a 24% decrease in the pay of musical artists. If this decrease is applied to the average salary of an artist in San Francisco, as estimated by ZipRecruiter, of $70,021 a year, the average musical artist would be making roughly $53,200 in one of the most expensive cities in the world. Needless to say, this “big net win for society” that Altman believes in seems to be at the expense of the very people that are providing it in the first place.
AI is fundamentally only a shallow attempt at recreating what makes art truly special. In the words of Rick Rubin from his book “The Creative Act: A Way of Being,” “Flaws are human, and the attraction of art is the humanity held in it. If we were machinelike, the art wouldn’t resonate. It would be soulless. With life comes pain, insecurity, and fear.” The pain makes the art, so how can something that can’t feel on the level of a human being ever truly understand the nuances of the human experience? To be frank, it can’t. The reason humans resonate with art in the first place is because it makes us feel seen. We feel that, in this crazy world, there is someone else who has gone through the thing that we have gone through, for better or for worse. So no matter how many vain attempts it may make, how can art be human without having all of the things that make us authentically human?

